Microsoft’s new “passwordless by default” is great but comes at a cost

Source: https://arstechnica.com/security/2025/05/microsoft-pushes-unphishable-logins-forward-with-new-sign-in-options/

Summary

Microsoft's new "passwordless by default" initiative aims to enhance online security by guiding new users away from passwords toward methods like the Microsoft Authenticator app, Windows Hello, or passkeys. This shift combats phishing, brute-force attacks, and password reuse, promising a more secure online experience. However, challenges exist. Technological barriers could exclude users lacking compatible devices, and user education is crucial for adoption. Privacy considerations surrounding biometric data collection also need careful attention. Despite these costs, this move, aligned with an industry-wide trend, represents a significant step toward a future where passwords are no longer necessary.

Full News Report

Here's the article: **Microsoft's New "Passwordless by Default" is Great, But Comes at a Cost** Microsoft is taking a bold step toward a password-free future. The tech giant has announced a "passwordless by default" initiative for Microsoft accounts, meaning new users will be guided away from traditional passwords towards more secure authentication methods. While this move is widely seen as **great** news for online security and user experience, the transition isn't without its **cost**, both for users and for Microsoft itself. The initiative, part of an industry-wide push for users to adopt passkeys, aims to make online accounts more resilient to phishing attacks and other credential-based threats. But how will this work, and what are the potential downsides? **What, Where, When, Why, and How: The Passwordless Push** * **What:** Microsoft is shifting towards "passwordless by **default**" authentication for new personal Microsoft accounts. This means that new users will be encouraged to use alternatives to passwords, such as the Microsoft Authenticator app, Windows Hello (biometric authentication), security keys, or passkeys stored on devices. * **Where:** This change affects new Microsoft accounts globally. It will be rolled out gradually, starting in specific regions and then expanding. * **When:** The rollout is underway, with Microsoft actively promoting passwordless options to new users and providing resources to existing users to make the switch. There isn't a firm cut-off date to force all users passwordless, but the trend is clear. * **Why:** The primary reason is enhanced security. Passwords are notoriously vulnerable to phishing, brute-force attacks, and human error (weak passwords, reuse of passwords). Passwordless methods, especially those leveraging cryptographic keys, are significantly more resistant to these attacks. Microsoft aims to reduce the risk of account compromises and data breaches. They also argue that passwordless authentication will improve user experience by simplifying login processes. * **How:** When creating a new Microsoft account, users will be guided through the setup of passwordless authentication methods. The exact flow might vary, but it will emphasize setting up Microsoft Authenticator or using Windows Hello. Users can still choose to create a traditional password if they insist, but they will be actively discouraged from doing so. For existing users, Microsoft provides tools and resources to transition to passwordless options, allowing them to remove their passwords entirely. **The Lure of Passwordless: A Security Game Changer** **Microsoft's** move highlights a growing consensus in the cybersecurity community: passwords are a relic of the past. The vulnerabilities associated with passwords are well-documented: * **Phishing:** Cybercriminals frequently trick users into entering their passwords on fake websites that look legitimate. Passwordless methods eliminate this risk since there's no password to steal. * **Brute-Force Attacks:** Automated tools can systematically try millions of password combinations to gain unauthorized access. Passwordless authentication, especially those that rely on hardware-backed security keys or biometric data, are far more difficult to crack. * **Password Reuse:** Many people reuse the same password across multiple accounts, making them vulnerable if one account is compromised. Passwordless methods like passkeys are unique to each website or service, so even if one is compromised, the others remain secure. * **Human Error:** Users often choose weak passwords or forget them entirely. Passwordless methods can streamline the login process and eliminate the need to remember complex passwords. The increased security offered by passwordless authentication is particularly important in today's threat landscape, where cyberattacks are becoming increasingly sophisticated and prevalent. The transition to **passwordless** methods represents a significant step toward a more secure online environment. **The Catch: The Cost of Convenience and Security** While the benefits of Microsoft's "passwordless by **default**" initiative are undeniable, there are potential **costs** and challenges to consider: ### **1. Technological Barriers and Accessibility** * **Device Dependency:** Passwordless methods often rely on specific devices, such as smartphones (for Microsoft Authenticator) or computers with biometric sensors (Windows Hello). Users without access to these technologies may be excluded. The digital divide already disproportionately affects lower-income individuals and communities. Microsoft needs to ensure that its passwordless solutions are accessible to everyone, regardless of their technological capabilities. * **Operating System Compatibility:** The compatibility of passwordless authentication methods across different operating systems and devices is another potential concern. While passkeys are aiming for cross-platform compatibility, the reality is that seamless integration across all devices isn't always guaranteed. This can create friction for users who switch between different devices or operating systems. * **Reliance on Infrastructure:** Passwordless authentication relies on the availability and reliability of supporting infrastructure, such as Microsoft's servers and authentication services. Outages or technical issues can prevent users from accessing their accounts, even if they have set up passwordless methods. This is a potential point of failure that needs to be carefully addressed. ### **2. User Education and Adoption** * **Learning Curve:** Some users may find it challenging to understand and adopt passwordless authentication methods, especially if they are not technically savvy. Clear and comprehensive user education is crucial to ensure that people can seamlessly transition to passwordless authentication. This includes providing step-by-step guides, video tutorials, and accessible support channels. * **Resistance to Change:** People are often resistant to change, even if it's for the better. Some users may be reluctant to abandon passwords, which they have been using for years. Overcoming this resistance requires demonstrating the benefits of passwordless authentication in a clear and compelling way. * **Account Recovery:** Setting up robust account recovery mechanisms is essential in case users lose access to their devices or encounter other issues. This might involve using backup codes, trusted contacts, or other verification methods. However, these recovery methods must also be secure to prevent unauthorized access. ### **3. Privacy Considerations** * **Data Collection:** Passwordless authentication methods, such as biometric authentication, may involve the collection of sensitive data. Microsoft needs to be transparent about how this data is collected, stored, and used. Users must have control over their data and be able to opt out of data collection if they choose. * **Security of Biometric Data:** Biometric data is particularly sensitive because it is unique to each individual. It is crucial to ensure that biometric data is stored securely and protected from unauthorized access. Any vulnerabilities in the security of biometric data could have serious consequences. * **Centralization of Authentication:** Relying on a single provider for authentication can create a single point of failure and increase the risk of data breaches. Diversifying authentication methods and allowing users to use multiple providers can mitigate this risk. **The Industry-Wide Trend: Passkeys and Beyond** **Microsofts'** "passwordless by **default**" initiative is not happening in isolation. It reflects a broader industry trend towards passwordless authentication, driven by the increasing security risks associated with traditional passwords. * **Passkeys:** The emergence of passkeys, a new standard for passwordless authentication, is a significant development. Passkeys are cryptographic keys that are stored securely on devices and can be used to log in to websites and apps without a password. They are supported by major technology companies, including Apple, Google, and Microsoft. * **FIDO Alliance:** The FIDO (Fast Identity Online) Alliance is an industry consortium that is promoting the development and adoption of passwordless authentication standards. The FIDO Alliance has played a key role in the development of passkeys and other passwordless technologies. * **Government Initiatives:** Governments around the world are also recognizing the importance of passwordless authentication. Some governments are implementing policies to encourage the adoption of passwordless methods in government agencies and critical infrastructure. **Conclusion: A Future Without Passwords?** Microsoft's "passwordless by default" initiative is a **great** step towards a more secure and user-friendly online experience. While the transition may come with some **costs** and challenges, the potential benefits of passwordless authentication are undeniable. The move aligns with a broader industry trend, spearheaded by the rise of passkeys and other passwordless technologies, and represents a significant shift in how we think about online security. As passwordless authentication becomes more widely adopted, the internet will be a safer and more convenient place for everyone. The future looks bright for a world where passwords are a distant memory. The question now is how smoothly and inclusively we can make that transition. Microsoft's success will depend on addressing the accessibility, usability, and privacy concerns that accompany this bold move.